What's in a Murder Mystery Kit (and What's Often Missing)
What is in a murder mystery kit: character sheets, clue cards, host guide and solution, plus the extras to check for and the pieces many kits leave out.
Quick answer: A murder mystery kit usually has character sheets, a host guide, clue cards released round by round, and a solution with a reveal. Better kits add an opening scene, voting slips, name cards and a timeline. Often missing: a plan for absent players, matching props, a menu and host-playing rules. Check the product page for each.
Last updated: November 2026
What Comes in a Murder Mystery Kit (and What Is Often Missing)
If you are buying your first murder mystery kit, it is hard to tell from a product page what you actually get. The photos show a box or a stack of nice-looking pages, and the description says "everything you need." Sometimes that is true. Sometimes it means character sheets and a solution and nothing else, and you find out on the afternoon of the party.
So this post goes through the contents of a typical kit piece by piece: what each one is for, what a good version looks like, and what to check before you pay. I am describing the category in general, not any one product, because kits vary a lot. One figure shows why. Global Growth Insights reports that 48% of new kit launches in 2024 feature multi-ending storylines, which tells you the category is still changing and that two boxes with the same price can hold quite different things. If you are still deciding whether a kit is the right route at all, our guide on what you need for a murder mystery party covers the whole shopping list, and the post on hosting without a kit covers the alternative.
What is actually in a murder mystery kit?
Almost every kit has the four pieces in the table below. If one is missing, you are not looking at a complete game.
| Piece | What it is for | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Character sheets | Give each guest a role, a secret and things to say | The number of sheets matches your guest list, and each one gives the guest something specific to do |
| Host guide | Tells the host the rules, the order of rounds and what to read aloud | Timing for each round, and what to do if the group stalls |
| Clue or evidence cards | The material guests argue about, revealed round by round | Clues for every round, some toward the culprit and some away |
| Solution and reveal | Explains who did it, how, why, and which clues prove it | It names the clues, not only the culprit, and it can be read aloud |
Each piece has a few things worth knowing, so here they are one at a time.
Character sheets
One sheet per guest. A good character sheet has a name, a short background, a relationship to the victim and to a few other characters, a secret, and a handful of questions the guest can ask. Some sheets also tell the guest what to say when asked certain things, and what to do if they are the culprit.
Check that the sheets differ enough in length and tone that the shy guest gets a workable role, and that none of them just says "act mysterious." Our post on how to write murder mystery characters explains what makes a sheet useful.
The host guide
This is a document for whoever runs the evening. It explains the rules, the order of rounds, what to read aloud and when to hand out each clue. Some kits keep the guide to a page. Others give a detailed script.
It should be written so you can follow it while also managing food and drinks. A host guide that is only the solution is not a host guide.
Clue or evidence cards
These are the pieces of evidence that get revealed round by round: a letter, a receipt, a photo, a note, a list of times. They are what the guests argue about, so their quality decides how good the game feels.
Look for clues in each round, with at least a few pointing toward the real culprit and a few away from it (the red herrings), written so guests can work something out without being told. For ideas on what good clues look like, see our post on how to create murder mystery clues and the guide to making evidence cards.
The solution and reveal
This is the page that explains who did it, how, why, and which clues prove it. Often it comes with a reveal script for the host to read aloud and, in some kits, a confession for the culprit.
A solution that just says "it was the butler" leaves the host to explain the logic, so check that it lists the clues that point to the culprit and that the reveal is written to be read aloud.
What do better kits add?
These pieces are common but not universal. They make the evening smoother, so look for them.
An opening scene or introduction is a short text the host reads to set up the crime. Without it you will be writing your own, which is fine, but it is extra work. Voting or accusation slips give each guest a simple sheet to write their guess on. They are easy to make yourself, but nice to have.
Name cards or badges carry the character's name for each guest, so people can find each other, which helps in a group where people do not know each other. A timeline lists the sequence of events on the night of the crime so the host can check clues against it, and this is where plot holes show up. Invitations are themed text or a template you can send out, which helps if you want guests to prepare. A costume or prop list suggests what each character might wear or carry, and good kits keep these simple.
None of these is essential for a first game, but if two kits cost about the same, the one with a timeline and an opening scene will cost you less preparation.
What is often missing from a kit?
These are the gaps I would check for before buying, because they decide whether the kit survives a real party. I would rather you find them on the product page than at six o'clock on the day.
Most kits are written for a fixed number of guests. If one cancels, the plot may have a hole, and if an extra person arrives, there may be no character for them. Look for a note on how to adapt. Our post on adapting for last-minute cancellations shows what to do when the kit does not say.
Many kits assume the host does not play, because the host guide reveals the culprit. If you want to join in, check whether the kit supports that. Our post on whether the host can play covers the options.
Some kits give you the clue as a plain text card. Others include a document designed to look like a real letter or receipt. The second feels better, but the first is what you will usually get, so if props matter to you, look at the product photos closely. Our guide to printable props and templates can help you make your own.
Few kits suggest what to serve or how to fit the game around a meal, so if you are hosting a dinner, you will build that yourself. Our post on food ideas for a murder mystery party is a starting point.
Kits also tend to give one format. If your evening is tight, you may want to cut a round, and if it is loose, you may want to add one, but a kit that says how is rare. Last, think about support. If a clue contradicts a sheet, or a character's secret does not match the solution, you will want to ask someone, so check whether the seller offers any way to do that.
How do physical, downloadable and generated kits differ?
The contents are mostly the same, but the format changes how you use them.
| Format | What you get | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical box | Printed cards in a box | Hosts who want something to hold and hand out | A missing card, or a fixed number of characters you cannot change |
| Downloadable kit | A set of files you print yourself | Starting cheaply and reprinting a lost page | You do the printing and the cutting |
| Generated game | A game made for your guest count and theme, usually opened on phones or printed | A cast that matches your group exactly | Less of a physical object in the box sense |
You can create a mystery for a specific number of guests, or read how a custom murder mystery is put together. None of these formats is better in general. Choose the one that matches your guests, your time and how much control you want over the story.
What should I check before I buy?
Copy this into your notes and tick it off for any kit you are considering.
- The number of character sheets matches my guest list.
- Each sheet has a secret and some questions to ask.
- The host guide has timing for each round.
- There are clues for every round, with at least one red herring.
- The solution names the clues that prove the culprit.
- There is a note on missing or extra players.
- It says whether the host can play.
- I know how much printing or setup is needed.
- I know what is not included, such as props, food and decorations.
If you cannot answer three or more of these from the product page, ask the seller or choose a kit that says. Our buying guide for murder mystery kits and the guide to murder mystery in a box go through more of this.
Frequently asked questions
What is included in a murder mystery party kit?
Usually character sheets for each guest, a host guide, clue or evidence cards, and a solution with a reveal. Extras may include invitations, name cards, voting slips and a timeline.
Do murder mystery kits come with props?
Some include printed documents that look like evidence, but most rely on you for physical props such as costumes, decorations and food. Check the product description, because "everything you need" can mean very different things.
How many people does a murder mystery kit work for?
Most are written for a fixed number of guests, often somewhere between six and twelve. Check that the number matches your guest list and look for notes on adapting.
Is a murder mystery kit enough to run the whole party?
It gives you the game, but not the rest of the evening. You still need to plan food, drinks, space and timing, and you may need to prepare printed materials.
What is the difference between a kit and a generated game?
A kit is written for a fixed set of characters. A generated game is created for your guest count and theme, so the number of characters matches your group. The structure, with character sheets, clues and a solution, is similar.
Can I use a kit with a different number of players?
Sometimes. You can usually drop a minor character or add a low-stakes one, but you need to check every sheet and clue for references to the character you changed.